The most recommended home defense shotgun isn’t what you think. Traditional gun store recommendations – despite many being featured in trusted collector guides – often miss crucial factors in home defense. Recent data shows specific features matter more than brand names. Understanding these key elements transforms how you approach home protection. Here’s the systematic approach that firearms experts actually use.
This content may contain affiliate links. If you wish to support us and use these links to buy something, we may earn a commission.
10. Stoeger M3500
Think of the Stoeger M3500 as a budget-friendly semi-auto with a price tag of just $679. This 12-gauge uses a clever inertia system that handles everything from light target loads to heavy defensive rounds without complaining. You’ll appreciate the fiber-optic front sight and ghost ring rear sight when the lights are low. They’ve made the bolt handle and release nice and big, which really helps when your adrenaline’s pumping and you need to operate the gun quickly.
9. Mossberg 940 Pro Tactical
Here’s a shotgun that takes the headache out of maintenance. The special coating on the inside parts means you can shoot 1,500 rounds before cleaning – that’s a lot of practice time! If you like using red dot sights, you’ll love how the slide comes ready for them – no extra parts needed. The redesigned loading area prevents those annoying pinches when you’re reloading quickly, which anyone who’s used shotguns will really appreciate.
8. Benelli SuperNova
The SuperNova brings some clever thinking to home defense. They’ve wrapped a steel frame in polymer, making it tough enough to handle rain, snow, or whatever else comes its way while also lightening the weapon up in the process. Two stocks are available for it – the traditional ComforTech stock that helps take some of the bite out of the heavy hitting loads – or a more tactical pistol grip and collapsible stock. Barrels are easy to swap out too, meaning you can keep different barrels on hand for anything from home defense to hunting.
7. Winchester SXP Defender
This isn’t your grandpa’s pump shotgun. The SXP Defender has a neat trick up its sleeve – an inertia-assisted pump action that helps you work the action faster and smoother than typical pump guns. The inside of the barrel gets a special chrome coating that fights off rust, while the rotating bolt head locks up tight every time. You’ll find it points naturally and cycles shells smoothly, even when you’re moving quickly.
6. Beretta 1301
When seconds count, the Beretta 1301 really shines. Its BLINK gas system cycles shells 36% faster than other shotguns, which is pretty impressive. They’ve made all the important parts bigger – like the charging handle and bolt release – so you can work them easily even under stress. The special barrel design helps keep your shot patterns tight while actually reducing how much kick you feel. That’s a win-win in our book.
5. Rock Island Armory VR80
If you’re used to AR-style rifles, you’ll feel right at home with the VR80. All the controls sit right where you’d expect them, and the gas system lets you run different types of shells reliably. The 5-round magazines make loading and unloading simple and quick. You can even adjust how the gas system works to match whatever shells you’re using that day.
4. Mossberg Maverick 88
Looking for a solid home defense shotgun that won’t empty your wallet? The Maverick 88 delivers the reliability Mossberg is famous for at a price under $250. It shares many parts with its more expensive cousin, the Mossberg 500, including the proven action and safety. The synthetic stock handles bumps and bad weather like a champ, and the barrel works great with defensive loads. If you’re interested in more reliable firearms, you’re welcome to have a look at our roundup of the most reliable pistols ever made.
3. Remington 870
The Remington 870 is like the Swiss Army knife of shotguns – simple, reliable, and ready for anything. The solid steel receiver and dual action bars mean this pump gun won’t bind up when you’re working the action quickly. With more than 11 million made, it’s clear why law enforcement agencies everywhere trust it. Points naturally, shoots smoothly, and just plain works – sometimes the simple things are the best things. Just make sure you’re on the lookout for a model made before Remington’s reputation took a serious hit over rust.
2. Benelli M4
When special forces units worldwide need a shotgun, many pick the Benelli M4 – and for good reason. The smart ARGO gas system (that stands for Auto-Regulating Gas-Operating) means it’ll run whatever shells you feed it. The grip feels natural, and the stock adjusts to fit different people or if you’re wearing heavy clothes. It’s like the luxury sports car of shotguns – Italian-made precision that performs when it counts. It’s expensive, yes. And it’s worth it.
1. Mossberg 500 and 590 Tactical Series
There’s a reason the Mossberg 500 and 590 series have been America’s go-to defensive shotguns for over 60 years. These guns just work, plain and simple. The dual extractors make sure your shells eject reliably, and the anti-jam elevator keeps things running smooth. Whether you’re right or left-handed, the safety sits right where your thumb naturally rests. At $350-500, you’re getting a proven defender that won’t let you down. The 590 kicks things up a notch with some extra features, but both models share that rock-solid Mossberg reliability.
