Tacoma vs. Raptor vs. Colorado: Which Is Worst?

These three premium off-road trucks excel in different terrains with unique capabilities and features.

Christen da Costa Avatar
Christen da Costa Avatar

By

Our editorial process is built on human expertise, ensuring that every article is reliable and trustworthy. AI helps us shape our content to be as accurate and engaging as possible.
Learn more about our commitment to integrity in our Code of Ethics.

Image: Gadget Review

Your off-road truck choice determines success or failure on the trail. Most drivers select the wrong vehicle and face unnecessary struggles. The difference between conquering terrain and getting stuck comes down to three elite options. Toyota, Ford, and Chevy each build distinctly capable trucks with specific terrain advantages.

We’ll reveal which of these off-road champions deserves your attention for true all-terrain dominance.

Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro: A Legacy of Off-Road Prowess

Toyota Tacoma
Image: Toyota of North Miami

Built to handle weekend adventures while serving as a daily driver, the Tacoma TRD Pro comes equipped with 2.5-inch FOX shocks that progressively absorb impacts on rough terrain. With 9.4 inches of clearance, you’ll clear most obstacles without damage. Its crawl control system handles throttle and braking on steep descents, letting you focus on steering.

Durability defines these trucks, with many owners reporting 150,000+ miles without major repairs. The 3.5L V6 delivers 278 horses—reliable power when miles from civilization. Inside, you’ll find materials designed for abuse rather than luxury. The Tacoma’s decades-long reputation as the mid-size off-road benchmark continues to influence the entire segment, challenging newcomers to match its balance of capability and practicality. Choosing the right off-road truck is crucial for tackling rough trails successfully. If you’re interested in high-performing vehicles beyond off-road models, check out our guide to the best cars for various driving needs.

Ford Ranger Raptor: The New Kid on the Block

Ford Ranger Raptor
Image: Drive

Engineered with desert racing DNA, the Ranger Raptor features FOX shocks that adjust 60 times every second to optimize suspension response. Under the hood, Ford’s EcoBoost V6 generates 405 horsepower that maintains performance where conventional trucks falter.

Engineers widened the track 4 inches per side for superior stability during high-speed cornering on loose surfaces. Seven terrain modes let you customize vehicle behavior for specific conditions. After punishing development runs across the Australian Outback and American Southwest, Ford created a mid-size truck that handles extreme terrain at speeds that would destroy lesser vehicles.

Chevy Colorado ZR2 Bison: The Rock Crawling Specialist

Chevy Colorado ZR2 Bison
Image: MotorTrend

For those seeking technical trail mastery, Chevy’s ZR2 Bison stands apart with Multimatic DSSV dampers that maintain precise tire contact across uneven terrain. Five boron steel armor plates protect vital components while front and rear locking differentials ensure traction regardless of wheel position.

Selecting the 2.8L Duramax diesel rewards you with 369 lb-ft of torque at just 2,000 RPM—ideal for controlled obstacle navigation. At 212.4 inches overall, it navigates tight trails that defeat larger trucks. This collaboration between Chevy and American Expedition Vehicles delivered factory-backed capability that previously required extensive aftermarket modification—perfect for tackling trails that would send stock trucks home defeated.

Suspension and Handling: A Deep Dive

Suspension and Handling
Image: Car and Driver

What lies beneath these trucks reveals their true purpose on the trail. Tacoma’s position-sensitive FOX shocks provide progressive resistance during compression while preventing harsh bottoming out. With 9.4 inches of front travel, they keep tires planted when terrain gets challenging.

The Ranger Raptor takes a high-tech approach with sensors constantly feeding data to adjust damping rates in real-time. Its 11.8 inches of front travel handles high-speed obstacles that would damage conventional trucks. These contrasting engineering philosophies—Toyota’s evolutionary approach versus Ford’s clean-sheet design—directly impact whether your truck excels at technical crawling or high-speed desert running.

Engine Performance and Powertrain

Engine Performance and Powertrain
Image: Ford Authority

How manufacturers power their off-road specialists reveals different priorities for tackling rough terrain. Tacoma’s naturally-aspirated 3.5L V6 delivers 278 horsepower without complexity—a reliable choice when service centers are distant memories.

Meanwhile, Ford packed the Ranger Raptor with a twin-turbo 3.0L EcoBoost generating 405 horses and 430 lb-ft of torque for conquering momentum-robbing terrain. The Colorado’s diesel option provides 369 lb-ft of torque just above idle with 20-30% better efficiency than gas engines—extending your range into remote areas without carrying extra fuel for those backcountry adventures where the nearest gas station might be several mountain ranges away.

Off-Road Technology and Features

Off-Road Technology and Features
Image: Car and Driver

Modern off-road trucks leverage electronics to expand capability beyond what mechanical systems alone can deliver. These technological advancements make driving off-road safer and more efficient. To further improve your truck’s performance and utility, explore the best car accessories for customization options. Tacoma’s Crawl Control acts as low-speed cruise control with five speed settings between 1-5 mph, handling throttle and braking while you navigate.

Taking tech integration further, the Ranger Raptor features seven drive modes that transform vehicle behavior. Baja mode allows controlled power slides while maintaining safety parameters. The evolution from purely mechanical systems to sophisticated electronic assistance has democratized technical terrain—letting weekend warriors tackle obstacles that once demanded years of experience.

Interior Comfort and Technology

Interior Comfort
Image: YT, TheTopher

Gone are the days when off-road specialists meant spartan accommodations inside. Tacoma’s cabin features water-resistant materials throughout high-touch areas. Its 7-inch touchscreen includes physical controls that work with gloves or during trail bouncing—practical touches for real-world use.

In contrast, the Ranger Raptor offers rally car-inspired bolstered seats that keep you positioned during aggressive maneuvers. Its digital instrument cluster provides six different layouts based on driving mode. This evolution from stripped-down utilitarian interiors to balanced functionality acknowledges these trucks serve double duty—tackling serious trails while still getting you comfortably to work Monday morning.

Exterior Design and Styling

Exterior Design and Styling
image: Motor1.com

Almost every aggressive styling element serves a functional purpose on modern off-road trucks. Tacoma’s distinctive hood scoop actively extracts engine heat during low-speed crawling when natural airflow diminishes. Its body lines enable 35-degree approach and 26-degree departure angles for obstacle clearance.

Why did Ford make the Ranger Raptor so wide? Those flared fenders accommodate an 8.5-inch wider track that provides stability during high-speed off-road driving. The front bumper maximizes approach angle to 31 degrees while integrating recovery points. This integration of function and form represents a remarkable evolution from early off-road packages that merely added skid plates to standard trucks.

Pricing and Value

Pricing and Value
Image: Top Speed

Smart truck buyers look past window stickers to understand true ownership costs. Tacoma models typically retain 70% of their value after three years—dramatically reducing actual ownership expenses despite higher initial pricing.

Comparing factory packages against aftermarket modifications reveals additional value. The Ranger Raptor includes approximately $15,000 in specialized components developed as an integrated system. Consider long-term maintenance requirements before signing—specialized components like remote-reservoir shocks eventually need service at premium prices. Historical reliability data suggests the Tacoma’s simpler systems often cost less to maintain after warranty coverage expires than the more complex electronics found in newer designs.

Share this Article



About Gadget Review’s Editorial Process

At Gadget Review, our guides, reviews, and news are driven by thorough human expertise and use our Trust Rating system and the True Score. AI assists in refining our editorial process, ensuring that every article is engaging, clear and succinct. See how we write our content here →